The Fear of Miscarriage After Infertility or Loss

Written By Gerri Mileva

You’ve made it to the positive test. Maybe after months. Maybe after years. Maybe after losses, injections, procedures, and heartbreak.

But instead of relief, something else sets in:
fear.

Fear that it won’t last.
Fear of another loss.
Fear of getting too attached.
Fear of letting yourself hope.

If you’ve been through infertility or pregnancy loss, joy is often tangled with anxiety. You’re not ungrateful. You’re not broken. You’re protecting yourself.

And that makes sense.

Why This Fear Runs Deep

When your path to pregnancy has been filled with uncertainty, or when you’ve beaten all the stats, it’s not easy to suddenly feel safe. Your brain and body are used to bracing for bad news. Even good news can feel like a setup.

Common fears after infertility or loss might include:

  • Constant worry that something is going wrong

  • Obsessive checking of symptoms (or lack of them) - also called hypervigilance

  • Feeling emotionally “numb” as a way to cope

  • Guilt for not feeling more excited

  • Panic before or during ultrasounds or appointments

  • Fear of sharing the news “too early”

  • Overanalyzing every sensation, cramp, or twinge

These are protective responses, not personal failures.

What Fear After Pregnancy Loss or Infertility Might Sound Like

  • “I’m terrified of getting attached.”

  • “I don’t trust my body anymore.”

  • “I feel like I’m waiting for the other shoe to drop.”

  • “I can’t let myself celebrate. What if it ends again?”

  • “Everyone tells me to enjoy it, but I just feel anxious.”

These thoughts are common. They don’t mean you’re not happy about the pregnancy. They mean your nervous system is doing its best to keep you safe after trauma.

You Are Not Alone and You Are Not “Too Negative”

There’s a lot of pressure to “think positively” once you’re pregnant (see previous post about toxic positivity). But positive thinking is not a shield against loss, and fear doesn’t cause miscarriage.

There is no evidence that anxiety, stress, or cautious feelings harm a healthy pregnancy.

You are allowed to feel scared. You are allowed to feel joy and terror in the same breath - or to pendulum between the two at record speed! You are still doing your best even on the days you’re just trying to get through.

How to Cope With the Fear of Miscarriage

Here are some strategies that might help:

1. Name the Fear Without Trying to Fix It

Say it plainly. “I’m afraid I will lose this pregnancy.” Naming it can lessen its grip.

2. Practice Grounding, Not Positive Thinking

Rather than trying to “stay hopeful,” try to stay present.
Today I am pregnant. Today I am okay. Today I am breathing. I am pregnant until proven otherwise.

3. Plan for Appointments With Emotional Safety in Mind

Bring a support person. Tell your provider what helps you feel safe. Let them know you have a history of loss.

4. Create Meaningful Rituals or Check-Ins

Some people light a candle, journal, or do something small each week to acknowledge the pregnancy. You don’t have to pretend everything is fine, you just get to be in it, your way.

5. Find a Provider Who Honours Your History

You deserve care that acknowledges your past, not dismisses it. You should not have to explain why you're anxious.

Resources for Support

Final Thought

You can feel afraid and still move forward.
You can feel guarded and still be connected.
You can be pregnant after loss and still grieving what came before.

You are not doing this wrong.
You are doing something incredibly brave.

Gerri Mileva
Next

When Rest Feels Like a Waste of Time: Learning to Slow Down Without Shame